CHOICE is good. Choice is healthy.
But too much choice can be overwhelming – just ask the child standing in front of a sweetshop counter full of treats.
Frugalware's latest distribution, codenamed 'Solaria' is like a Linux sweetshop and, like that small boy who does not know what to spend his pennies on, it left me feeling overwhelmed.
Actually, it also left me feeling slightly underwhelmed, too, if it is possible to feel both ways simultaneously.
The last time I reviewed Frugalware it was in its 0.4 'Wanda' period and I was very impressed by it.
But this latest version left me feeling unsatisfied: It is like choosing the brightest, most tempting sweet then finding it tastes bland.
Anyway, enough with the analogies.. to the detail. Here are the main release notes from this Hungary-based distribution:
* Up to date base system: Linux kernel 2.6.26, Glibc 2.8 and GCC 4.3.1
* Updated desktop packages: GNOME 2.22, OpenOffice.org 2.4.1 and Firefox 3.0.1
* Setup: Improved support for machines with multiple network cards, the usb installer is now easier to start, fixed/documented installation in virtualbox/vmware.
* Improved graphical tools: FUN (update notifier) now supports news notifications.
* 6400 changes, including 568 new packages, 2279 updated packages and 926 closed tasks.
Solaria is a 4GB-plus DVD download, so you had better be sure you want to try it.
The reason it is such a hefty download is that Solaria crams in more desktop environments and window managers than you can shake a stick at.
You get: Blackbox; GNOME; GNOME with Openbox; KDE; KDE with Openbox; MWM; metacity; Openbox; TWM and XFCE4.
Does it not seem strange that a distribution bearing the word “frugal”
[frugal: economical, thrifty, avoiding waste] in its title should offer so many options?
When you boot into Solaria you are greeted by a lovely pastel yellow boot option screen (I do not know why but it made me think of 'I Dream Of Jeannie'!), the theme of which is continued as the system loads.

Which makes it all the more odd that once you load any of the various desktop environments, things take a decidedly nasty, bland turn.
Take a look at the two screenshots below – the first is from Frugalware 0.4, the second from 0.9.


See what I mean?
The background wallpaper is a very minor issue but you have to wonder why the Frugalware team went from the distinctive look of Wanda to the drab look of Solaria.
But the look of Solaria is a minor irritation when you compare it with the menu structure.
Of the various desktop environments, the defaul KDE desktop is the calmest place to be.
The rest? A horrid mess.
Take a look at the screenshot below of the GNOME 'Others' submenu, and tell me that is not confusing and badly implemented – and all you can see are the entries from 'A' to 'I', there are dozens more after those.

Still in GNOME, there are seven icons placed on the desktop: Computer, Steve's Home, Network Servers, System, Trash, Trash (again) and Home.

Two of these – Home and System – do nothing, and who needs two Trash folders?
Further, the Preferences menu contains a lot of entries you would normally find in the GNOME Administration men, such as Network, Printers, Hardware and Wireless.
Things do not get much better when you load the Xfce desktop where, given that this is a lightweight environment, the menus are still jammed full of options and the desktop has the same pointless icon duplication.
Of all the DEs/WMs available in Solaria, only KDE appears to have had any care and attention lavished on it, but even the KDE 3.5.9 desktop hardly sets the heather alight in terms of its appearance.
This poor desktop organisation is very odd in a distribution which is, at heart, still very good indeed.
Frugalware is reasonably straightforward to install – maybe not the most newbie-friendly install out there, but not too taxing so long as you pay attention.
Its hardware recognition is reasonably good – most of my bits and bobs where detected and configured during the install (on a P4, 3.4GHz with 1024MB of RAM, wired ethernet broadband, Acer AL1912 19inch LCD, 80GB hard drive partition).
I had opted not to install the Frugalware bootloader because I prefer to edit the Linux Mint GRUB boot menu.lst file on my main partition to handle my test partition too.
As I mentioned earlier, Solaria is a massive download because so many packages are included: It is hard to imagine there is something major missing that you might desperately need.
Frugalware uses the Pacman package system which, when combined with a nice graphical package manager, Gfpm, is a complete, comprehensive and reliable way of managing your system.

In terms of multimedia performance, I had a mixed experience.
Solaria comes with the key multimedia codecs – libdvdcss, win32, gst good, bad and ugly – preinstalled, which saves a lot of initial messing around.
However, whenever I tried to play movie trailers via Firefox on the Apple website, the browser crashed, and YouTube videos played but with no sound.
Thinking about it, by this stage I had not heard a peep out of Solaria – I had to rerun alsaconf to get my onboard Realtek sound going.
There is one further irritation I had to deal with. For some reason Solaria's installation sets your desktop dpi to a 'default' setting which is actually 72dpi, and not the usual, more usable 96dpi – since when has 72dpi been a 'default' setting?
In terms of system stability, I have no major issues to report, certainly in terms of the KDE desktop.
I did have some weird login problems with the Xfce desktop when, on my first boot into it, I got an error message telling me:
“Could not look up the internet address for Frugalware. This will prevent Xfce from operating correctly. It may be possible to correct this problem by adding Frugalware to the /etc/hosts on your system.”
Odd one that, never had that happen to me before – I just continued on through and everything seemed to work.
Frugalware is the only Linux distribution I know of which requires you to enter the root password before it will power down your PC – and I have no idea why it does that.
To conclude, there is actually a very solid, well-equipped distribution at the heart of Frugalware 0.9, but after some very disappointing first impressions it requires far too much system housekeeping to make it a distribution I can recommend.
The bland looks, the messy, overwhelming menus and a general feeling that Solaria was rushed out made this quite a major disappointment, especially after my experiences with Wanda way back.
Home page:
http://frugalware.org/User forums:
http://forums.frugalware.org/Download Solaria:
http://frugalware.org/download